By Jason Sibert
I’ve always admired Switzerland for so many reasons – its beauty, its wealthy economy, its vibrant democracy, and its social-democratic economy, even though the country isn’t as social-democratic as Sweden and the Nordic countries, which are so admired by Bernie Sanders and his followers among today’s Democrats.
One of the most fascinating things about Switzerland’s democracy is that it’s a semi-direct democracy, meaning a political system in which citizens elect representatives but also retain powerful direct democratic tools to shape legislation. The essence of a democracy – first emerging in ancient Greece (although in a limited form) – is that people are in possession of enough reason to choose the laws they live under by some mechanism. In the United States, and in many other countries, we do this by selecting legislators to make the laws. Switzerland has a legislative body elected by the people, but it can bypass legislators by passing laws via referendum. The Swiss use different tools to shape the legislative process. They can amend the Constitution via popular initiative. With 100,00 signatures, a vote will be taken on an amendment. From there, the amendment must draw a majority of the votes in most cantons (the Swiss version of US states). Citizens can also veto a law passed by parliament by collecting 50,000 signatures in 10 days. If they succeed, the law is suspended until a referendum is held, and if citizens vote to abolish it, it is abolished. In addition to the federal level, citizens also vote on cantonal and municipal referendums.
The Swiss have perfected a way to bypass politicians when needed. We do have something similar in our country, at the state level. My home state of Missouri adopted a citizen‑initiated constitutional amendment process back in 1908. That year, voters approved Amendment Three to the state constitution, which added the initiative and referendum powers to the Missouri Constitution. That made Missouri the seventh state in the nation to adopt statewide citizen‑initiated ballot measures.
However, our experiment with Swiss-style citizen democracy has recently become controversial. Under current state law, such ballot measures require a simple statewide majority for passage, a process that has been used in recent years to grant abortion rights, create paid sick leave, expand Medicaid, and legalize marijuana. In a move backward, the Republican legislature repealed paid sick leave in 2025. In another attempt to move backward, Republican Rep. Ed Lewis first proposed Amendment Four to the Missouri Constitution, which would have required citizen-led ballot initiatives to win a majority in each of Missouri’s congressional districts, boundaries that are drawn by state lawmakers.
It would have created “the strictest passage threshold in the country for citizen-initiated ballot measures only,” said Hannah Ledford, the deputy director of the Fairness Project, a group that supports citizen initiative processes, in a recent report. She added it could have left Missouri’s direct democracy process “functionally dead.” On August 4, Missouri voters went to the polls and rejected Amendment Four. Remember this is a red state, and what baffles me is how Missourians support semi-direct democracy, abortion rights, paid sick leave, Medicaid expansion, and legalized marijuana in amendments but don’t support politicians who believe in such things.
A big part of social democracy is supporting democratic forms, unlike revolutionary communism. Of course, those norms are under attack by various right-wing populist movements around the world, and semi-direct democracy is just one democratic norm under threat. Republicans have also sought to make it harder for citizen-led constitutional amendments to pass in other states. In November, North Dakota and South Dakota voters will decide whether to bump the threshold up from a statewide majority to 60%. In Utah, a similar measure will appear on the fall ballot, specifically related to tax increases.
In the fight to protect our democratic republic, semi-direct democracy is one of the most important battlegrounds. Will we, as citizens of the USA, fight to protect semi-direct democracy? We’ll see.
Jason Sibert is the Lead Writer of the Peace Economy Project.