Charlie et Les Juifs

It’s been a week since the Paris shootings and we’ve all had some time to think about what happened. Here are some things that have been bouncing around in my head:

Freedom of the Press is a sacred right in France, but we shouldn’t confuse that with free speech. In France, hate speech is prohibited. Holocaust denial is prohibited. Political candidates are not allowed to make disparaging remarks about other candidates. In fact, Charlie Hebdo has had several run-ins with the law over the years. A free press is a key to preventing totalitarian government, but it should respect that freedom and use it for its intended purpose. Mocking religious and political authority is a fair use of that freedom.

We also have a free press here in the U.S., but our news is “self-censored”. Organizations like the New York Times say they don’t print material when the author’s primary goal is offending others. They say that’s not news. It would be nice to think that such self-censorship is founded on lofty goals, but here in the U.S. we must always remember that reporting news is a business. Newspapers print what is good for business and censor what is bad for business. When they say they don’t want to offend, they mean their advertisers and subscribers. This is why you see Fox News offending just about everyone except their white audience— it’s good business for them. Newspapers and TV outlets tell people what they want to hear. That’s good for business, but not our democracy.

JeSuisCharlieMany people, myself included, jumped on the “Je Suis Charlie” campaign to express fraternity with the staff at Charlie Hebdo. Additionally, many jumped on the “Je Suis Ahmed” campaign to express empathy with Muslims like Ahmed Merabet, the police officer who was murdered outside the Charlie offices. There was still a third campaign “Je Suis Juif” to express empathy for the French Jews after four Jews were murdered in a kosher supermarket on Friday. That last one got very little traction. While people are quick to associate themselves with murdered writers, cartoonists, and assimilated Muslims, not many will associate themselves with Jews. When Jews are murdered there is always an underlying assumption that they somehow deserved it— that they brought this on themselves. Pick your raison du jour, but this has been going on for 2,000 years. Perpetrators always feel their reason is authentic and unique, and thus there’s no reason to believe this ever will stop.

Some people have since rejected the “Je Suis Charlie” mantra, instead saying that they support free press but that Charlie has abused its privilege. Others say that citizens have no right not to be offended. If you don’t like what someone is saying, turn it off, don’t buy it, walk away. I find a certain amount of hypocrisy with Americans who say “je suis Charlie”, and yet are offended by just about everything. My FB and Twitter feeds seem like an endless stream of people and publications saying, “can you believe he said that?!!” Americans may be the most easily offended people on the planet, and so we invented political correctness. Everyday someone feels a need to apologize for something. Yesterday it was congressman who used the names Hitler and Obama in the same tweet. Don’t dare say you hate Brussels sprouts!

I find an interesting paradox with labeling of terrorism in America. If murders are committed by Muslims, they are terrorists. If a white man murders people at a Jewish community center, he committed a hate crime. If a white man detonates a pipe bomb at an NAACP office, he committed a hate crime. And if tea partiers murder cops in Las Vegas… well, we just pretend that never happened. The use of the different language is meant to say that Muslims all work together to terrorize Americans. Whereas, white racists who commit acts of terror are lone wolves who have mental illness of some kind. Was there ever any doubt that the goal of the KKK was to terrorize blacks, Jews, and Catholics? They still exist, and yet, our news organizations will not call them terrorists. Neither will our police and political leaders call them terrorists. At the Bundy Ranch in Nevada, tea partiers aimed automatic weapons at federal agents who were planning to evict them. No one called them terrorists. More self censoring and political correctness so that they don’t offend (whites).

Israeli PM Benjamin “Bibi” Netanyahu elbowed his way into the Paris march on Sunday. His motives are solely political. There is an upcoming election and it’s not clear how he will fare. So he was quick to associate himself with murdered Jews. Aside from using the massacre for campaign purposes, I was dismayed by his statements to French Jews that Israel is their home and they should leave France. Yes, of course, Jews all over the world know that they can flee to Israel when they are in danger. But the clear implication in his statement is that French Jews aren’t really French. This plays right into the hands of neo-fascist groups like Front National (FN) who claim that Muslims, Jews, and Roma aren’t really French. This Euro-tribalism is ominously spreading throughout Europe. It is even present in relatively progressive states like Sweden, where the Sweden Democrats party has about 14% of the parliament. By encouraging support for the FN, Bibi’s speech makes life more difficult for Jews who stay in France, but that is the least of his concerns.

The shootings in Paris won’t stop Charlie. They are already back in business. But it could further an exodus of Europe’s largest Jewish community. While Zionists call for all Jews to return to Israel, many Jews like life outside the walled city. And they are serving a purpose. Diaspora Jews have been labeled as the “canary in the coal mine”. That old phrase described miners using canaries to detect poisonous gas. The death of the canary signaled imminent danger to the miners. A mass exodus of French Jews could signal danger for all of France.

Weiss Withdraws, Warren Wins

Senator Elizabeth Warren put another scalp on her belt yesterday as it became known that Antonio Weiss, a long-time Lazard executive, had asked the President not to re-submit his name for a high Treasury Department post. Warren, who is being urged by some progressive groups to run for the Presidency, has been leading a fight to curtail the practice of a revolving door between government jobs and Wall Street. Last month she led the fight against a Citigroup-written clause in the spending bill and called attention to the number of former Citigroup executives who have moved in and out of the Obama and earlier administrations. Last summer she was part of the effort to prevent the nomination of Lawrence Summers, a leading corporate Democrat, for Federal Reserve Chairman.

Presidential candidate or not, Warren is playing a critical role in the development of a resurgent progressive wing of the Democratic Party. With her gutsy,”take no prisoners” attitude, she is giving leadership to the activist progressive-social democratic heart of the Party, and she is also setting out a comprehensive economic program for alleviating poverty and rebuilding the middle class, as she did at the AFL-CIO Wages Summit last week. In the months ahead, Warren may give us the answer to the question “Where is Harry Truman
when we need him?”

Posted in Uncategorized by Eldon Clingan. 2 Comments

Your Chance to Support a Progressive Israel

Social Democrats USA is a proud, if critical, supporter of the State of Israel. We also believe strongly in the right of Palestinian Arabs to have their own state. Jewish members who support these principles have an opportunity to give practical effect to their views by voting for Hatikvah, the Progressive Zionist slate, in the election for the World Zionist Congress. The election begins on Tuesday, January 13th, and you can get full details at

The Hatikvah slate is a coalition of Ameinu (Labor Zionist), Partners for Progressive Israel, Habonim Dror and Hashomer Hatzair, which many of us in SDUSA consider fraternal organizations. Among the prominent delegate candidates on the Hatikvah slate are Theodore
Bikel, the actor-folksinger, Debra DeLee, the CEO of Americans for Peace Now, and Randi Weingarten, the President of the American Federation of Teachers.

Posted in Uncategorized by Eldon Clingan. 1 Comment

Warren to Keynote Live-streamed AFL- CIO Wages Summit on Wednesday

Senator Elizabeth Warren will deliver the keynote address at the AFL-CIO sponsored National Summit on Raising Wages on Wednesday, January 7th. Participants at the conference, including Secretary of Labor Thomas Perez, will be discussing concrete steps to raise wages for working people and to begin reducing the gross inequality that characterizes the U.S. economy. The conference will start at 8:30 A.M. on Wednesday and will be live-streamed on computers. It can be accessed at

Posted in Uncategorized by Eldon Clingan. No Comments

Education for Action

An almost universal activity of social democratic movements is education, broadly defined. We believe, sometimes implicitly, that we can build a better world by reason and that the support of the people must be gained by facts and arguments, rather than by appeals to prejudice and emotion. We believe that reasoned discussion, rather than violence, is the only way to a truly democratic society.

Social democratic education starts with the membership of the organization, and certainly that is true with SDUSA. The goal is to have every Social Democrat be fully knowledgeable and armed with information about proposals to improve the lives of Americans. This is especially important for our organization because we are small and widely scattered. Most of us work politically with progressives who are not members of SDUSA, and it is vital that a unique Social Democratic voice be heard.

SDUSA has built and is building a multi-part educational program.

The oldest part is the blog which you are now reading. On the blog are comments about current political events, news about SDUSA, “think pieces” and probably the occasional rant.
There is also an opportunity for the reader to praise, criticize or just add to the discussion. The blog reaches a larger group than the membership, and we hope that it will serve to attract new members.

Our Facebook page is doing an excellent job of calling attention to issues on the blog and on other sites. Although the nature of Facebook does not allow extended discussions, it reaches a larger audience than the membership, and, we hope, gives readers a quick view of SDUSA ideas.

SDUSA members will know that in 2014 we began publication of a monthly series of in-depth papers on such subjects as the War on Poverty, inequality, minimum wages, and problems of Social Democracy for the 21st century. These papers are primarily the work of generous individuals and progressive think tanks, who give us permission to reproduce their work. We thereby are able make available the research and conclusions of distinguished investigators of social problems. This series will continue.

Sometimes we want to get out to the membership smaller amounts of information than the monthly pamphlet series makes possible, so we started a “Short Takes” series. These 1 to 6 page papers will be published occasionally, as need requires. The first “Short Take” has gone out to the membership and is Bernie Sanders 12 point economic program.

We have started a DVD lending library that is available without cost to members. The library includes such DVDs as one on the life of Bayard Rustin and Robert Reich’s “Inequality.” Of course, members can play these at home for their own education, but we hope that they will also be used for public meetings of local progressives.

Our recent national convention determined to establish a quarterly conference call on significant issues. The first conference is tentatively planned for the middle of February and will be on the subject “Achieving Full Employment.” The conference call will give all of us the opportunity to share ideas on issues of importance to Social Democrats, as well as the chance to meet personally with other members.

Has this educational program piqued your interest? Then why not join SDUSA and participate? The form to join is on this page!

Posted in Uncategorized by Eldon Clingan. No Comments